Ana içeriğe atla

How Does a Library Die? Part 4: Baghdad (Digital Age) – Silence in the Cloud



There was a time when books were the vessels of knowledge. People travelled from distant cities to visit libraries, spent hours among the shelves, and searched through one text to find another. Accessing knowledge required effort, time and patience. The loss of a single book could sometimes mean the disappearance of an idea that might never be recovered for centuries.

Today, however, we no longer need to visit a library to access information. We type a few words and, within seconds, can reach millions of documents, books, photographs and records. Our books have become digital files, archives have moved to servers, and libraries have found their way onto online platforms. We have come to believe that all of this is safely stored in an invisible space called the cloud.

Yet the cloud is not an unlimited memory suspended somewhere in the sky. It is a very tangible infrastructure consisting of data centres, physical servers, cables, energy systems and the companies that manage them, spread across different parts of the world. It depends on electricity, technical maintenance, financial resources and political conditions.

This leaves us facing a different question: Can a library disappear today without ever being burned down?

The story of Baghdad offers a powerful starting point for thinking about this question.

From the 8th century onwards, Baghdad, the capital of the Abbasid Caliphate, became one of the most important centres of science, culture and trade in the Islamic world. Scholars, translators, physicians, mathematicians, philosophers and writers from different regions gathered in a city alive with intellectual activity.

One of the best-known symbols of this intellectual world was the Bayt al Hikma, or House of Wisdom. Its name became particularly prominent during the reign of Caliph al Ma'mun, and it is closely associated with the translation of Greek, Persian and Indian sources into Arabic. Works written in different languages were translated, studied and used as foundations for new research.

However, it would be misleading to imagine the House of Wisdom as a modern university or research centre bringing together every scientific discipline under one roof, complete with specialised departments and a clearly defined institutional structure. Historical information about its organisation, operation and physical location is limited. The translation movement itself did not take place exclusively within this institution; it also developed in court circles, private collections and various scholarly communities.

Baghdad's intellectual strength did not depend on a single building or library. The city contained palace collections, private libraries, madrasas and different circles where books were produced and studied. Books were purchased, copied, lent and circulated among scholars.

What made Baghdad significant, therefore, was not simply the number of books it possessed. Its true wealth lay in an environment where knowledge could move between languages, cultures and generations.

In 1258, the Mongol army under Hülegü Khan laid siege to Baghdad. The city was then in the final period of the Abbasid Caliphate, whose political power had weakened considerably compared with previous centuries. Following the siege, Baghdad was captured and suffered widespread destruction and loss of life. The caliphal order came to an end.

The event became one of the most devastating turning points in the history of the Islamic world. The sack of Baghdad, the killing of its inhabitants, the destruction of buildings and the disruption of cultural life severely affected an intellectual heritage that had taken centuries to develop.

One of the most striking elements of the story is the account that books were thrown into the Tigris River, turning its waters black with ink. For centuries, this image has been repeated as a powerful symbol of the destruction of an entire civilisation's memory.

Yet we need to distinguish between historical accounts and events supported by firm evidence. There is no doubt that the Mongol invasion caused immense destruction in Baghdad. However, there is insufficient evidence to establish that every library in the city was destroyed or that books were collectively thrown into the river.

Historian Michal Biran's research shows that intellectual life in Baghdad did not come to a complete halt after the Mongol conquest. Libraries continued to exist, books continued to circulate and new collections were established. There is also evidence that the library of the Mustansiriyya Madrasa remained active in the period following the conquest.

This does not make the destruction of 1258 any less significant. On the contrary, it helps us understand its historical reality more accurately. A city's memory may not be erased entirely by a single attack, but the institutions, people and networks that sustain it can suffer devastating damage.

In Baghdad's story, what matters is not only the books that were lost, but also the transformation of the world in which knowledge was produced and transmitted.

Centuries later, the very idea of a library began to change. Books were digitised, manuscripts were scanned, and newspapers and photographs were transferred to electronic archives. Collections that had once been accessible only to researchers in a particular city could now be explored from different parts of the world through the internet.

This transformation created enormous opportunities for humanity. Accessing a digital copy of a rare manuscript no longer requires travelling thousands of kilometres. Old newspaper collections, historical maps, sound recordings and photographs can now be preserved in online archives.

Digitisation can also contribute to the preservation of physical works. A digital copy of a manuscript can reduce the need to handle the original document repeatedly. Collections that become inaccessible because of war or natural disasters can still be studied through copies stored elsewhere.

But there is an important distinction: creating a digital copy of a work does not mean preserving it forever.

Digital files also depend on specific technologies. Software changes, file formats become obsolete, storage devices deteriorate, and older systems become increasingly difficult to operate. A file that we can open easily today may become inaccessible a few decades from now because the necessary software or hardware is no longer available.

This is one of the issues repeatedly emphasised in the digital preservation work of the Library of Congress. The fact that a file has been stored on a computer does not guarantee that its contents will remain readable and usable in the future. Preserving the data itself is only part of the task; the technical environment and the information required to interpret it must also be maintained.

In other words, preserving a digital work requires more than ensuring that the file does not disappear. Its meaning and usability must also survive.

Cloud systems are among the greatest conveniences of the digital age. We can store photographs, documents, articles and archives in spaces that are accessible from different devices. Large institutions can also keep millions of documents in data centres.

Yet the cloud is not, by itself, a preservation policy. The storage space offered by a service provider is not the same as a guarantee of long term archival security.

A company may discontinue a service, change its pricing policy or restrict users' access. An account may be closed, a platform may be acquired, or a service used for years may simply disappear. If users cannot transfer their data to another system, digital archives may suddenly become inaccessible.

Moreover, the memory of the digital world consists of far more than the archives of large institutions. Personal blogs, independent publications, online magazines, forums, digital artworks, social media posts and individual research projects are also part of our cultural heritage.

A significant portion of this material is never transferred into any formal archival system. When a website closes, years of writing and discussion can disappear with it. When a platform deletes its historical posts, it may erase not only users' memories but also traces of a particular period in society.

And what disappears in the digital world is not always the file itself. A link may stop working, the source of an image may be deleted, or the information showing when and under what circumstances a text was created may be lost.

Preserving the content of a document is important, but the context that allows us to understand it is just as valuable.

The destruction of a traditional library is often visible. Shelves are emptied, buildings are damaged and books disappear as a result of fire, war, floods or looting. It is possible to understand the scale of the loss by examining what remains.

In the digital world, however, loss can occur much more quietly.

We may not notice that a file can no longer be opened, that a database has become inaccessible or that the old pages of a website have been deleted until years later. Sometimes the loss becomes apparent only when a researcher follows an old link, a journalist searches for a previously published document, or a reader tries to find an article they read years ago.

One of the greatest problems with digital archives is precisely this invisibility. We assume that information must still exist somewhere. We believe that a text, photograph or recording we once encountered online must have been preserved. Yet being published on the internet does not mean that a work has been permanently archived.

UNESCO's Charter on the Preservation of Digital Heritage emphasises that digital heritage must remain accessible not only to today's users but also to future generations. Protecting this heritage requires institutional responsibility, legal frameworks and long-term policies, as well as technical infrastructure.

The real question facing the libraries of the digital age, therefore, is not how much data we can store, but how long we can preserve it.

Another issue surrounding the libraries of the digital age is the relationship between access and ownership.

When we buy a printed book, we can place it on our own shelf and read it again whenever we wish. With a digital book, however, what we often possess is not the work itself but the right to access it under certain conditions. When a platform's rules, licensing terms or technical restrictions change, we may lose access to content that was previously available to us.

The same applies to academic databases, digital journals and online archives. While information is multiplying in digital environments, access to it can increasingly fall under the control of certain companies, institutions and subscription systems.

This creates an important contradiction: even as access to knowledge becomes easier than at any other time in human history, its permanence and availability are becoming dependent on new systems.

A locked library door and restricted access to a digital archive due to subscription, licensing or account conditions are not the same thing. Yet both raise a common question: Who will have access to knowledge, and for how long?

Cultural memory cannot consist solely of documents preserved in someone else's possession. The ability of societies to investigate their past, compare different perspectives and access information independently is also part of keeping that memory alive.

None of these risks means that digital archives cannot be preserved. On the contrary, methods developed in the field of digital preservation offer important ways to prevent such losses.

Creating multiple copies of a document, storing those copies in different physical locations, regularly checking file integrity and migrating outdated file formats to newer systems are among the fundamental elements of this work.

Guidelines on the long-term preservation of digital heritage prepared by UNESCO and PERSIST also emphasise the importance of backups, active management and metadata management. They recommend that important digital works should not be kept in a single location, but preserved in multiple copies across different physical sites.

The Library of Congress also monitors its digital storage systems, follows technological developments and transfers data to new environments when necessary. This approach demonstrates that digital preservation is not a one-time task but an ongoing responsibility.

The role of the librarian is changing as well. We are no longer speaking only about people who classify books, place them on shelves and help readers find them. Digital archivists, data managers, software developers, preservation specialists and researchers now work together to build the libraries of the future.

In the digital age, librarianship must consider not only where information is stored, but also how it will be read in the future.

It would be inaccurate to draw a direct equivalence between the destruction Baghdad suffered in 1258 and the risks facing digital archives today. In the former case, the destruction was caused by war and political violence; in the latter, the threats arise from technological, economic, institutional and political dependencies.

Yet the two periods share a fundamental question: Who will protect the memory of a society?

In Baghdad, knowledge lived in palace libraries, madrasas, private collections and the work of scholars. When the city's political order changed, these networks were affected as well. Nevertheless, the production and transmission of books did not come to a complete end.

Today, our digital memory is scattered across personal computers, university servers, public archives, commercial cloud systems and independent websites. This distribution can sometimes offer an advantage in terms of security, but without a shared commitment to preservation, it can also lead to serious losses.

Publishing a text online is not enough to leave it to the future. It must be preserved, backed up, kept accessible, properly documented and maintained in formats that can be read by other technologies.

Perhaps the greatest misconception of the digital age is the belief that everything is stored somewhere. Yet not every file in the cloud is permanent. The shelves of an invisible library can also become empty.

The story of Baghdad reminds us that knowledge depends not only on the period in which it is produced, but also on the continued existence of people and institutions willing to preserve it.

Once, we asked whether books had been thrown into the river and whether entire libraries had been destroyed. Today, we must ask the same question in a different form: Which files will we be unable to open tomorrow? Which archives will become inaccessible? Which digital traces will we no longer be able to remember?

Because a library no longer lives only within stone walls. Sometimes it exists on a server, sometimes in a data centre, and sometimes in a digital archive created over many years by a person who has no other copy of their work.

And perhaps, in the digital age, the true death of a library does not occur when its data is deleted, but on the day when no one remembers that it ever existed.



      References

  • Biran, Michal. “Libraries, Books, and Transmission of Knowledge in Ilkhanid Baghdad.” Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient, vol. 62, nos. 2–3, 2019, pp. 464–502.

  • De Nicola, Bruno. “The Mongol Conquest of Baghdad and Its Aftermath: Manuscript Production and Intellectual Life.” Medieval Worlds, no. 22, 2025, pp. 14–44.

  • Hirschler, Konrad. The Written Word in the Medieval Arabic Lands: A Social and Cultural History of Reading Practices. Edinburgh University Press, 2012.

  • Library of Congress. “Bit Level Preservation and Long Term Usability.” Digital Collections Management Compendium.

  • Library of Congress. “Sustainability of Digital Formats: Planning for Library of Congress Collections.”

  • Library of Congress. “Responsibility for Digital Collections Content and Storage Systems.”

  • UNESCO. Charter on the Preservation of Digital Heritage. 2003.

  • UNESCO / PERSIST. The UNESCO/PERSIST Guidelines for the Selection of Digital Heritage for Long-Term Preservation.

Yorumlar

Bu blogdaki popüler yayınlar

The Odyssey #2: Humanity and Fate — Between Free Will and the Inevitable

  How much of a person's life is truly their own to determine? No one chooses where they are born, the family they grow up in, the society that shapes their early years, or the opportunities that will come their way. Long before we develop the ability to make decisions, life has already placed us within certain circumstances. Yet as we grow older, we are expected to choose between the possibilities before us and take responsibility for the lives we create. There is a curious contradiction here. We live within circumstances we never chose, yet we try to shape our lives through the choices we make. We are neither entirely masters of our own will nor merely passive observers of what happens to us. The tension between freedom and fate is one of the oldest questions humanity has ever asked. Homer's Odyssey explores this tension through a world in which human beings confront the gods, the forces of nature, and the limits of their own existence. In the ancient Greek worldview, human ...

Taoizm — Yol ile Uyum İçinde Yaşamanın Kadim Sanatı

İnsan çoğu zaman hayatı kontrol edebileceğine inanarak yaşar. Geleceğini planlar, karşısına çıkabilecek sorunları önceden çözmeye çalışır, istediği sonuçlara ulaşmak için çaba gösterir. Belirsizlikten hoşlanmaz; olayların kendi belirlediği yönde ilerlemesini ister. Fakat doğada böyle bir telaş göremeyiz. Nehirler önlerine çıkan her engeli ortadan kaldırmaya çalışmadan yollarına devam eder. Ağaçlar büyümek için başka ağaçlarla yarışmaz, mevsimler de birbirini beklemeden kendi döngüsünü sürdürür. Çin düşünce tarihinin en eski geleneklerinden biri olan Taoizm, insanın doğayla ve evrenle kurduğu ilişkiye bu açıdan yaklaşır. İnsanın dünyayı yönetmeye çalışmasından çok, içinde yaşadığı düzeni anlamasıyla ilgilenir. Bu düşünceye göre insan, evrenden ayrı ve onun üzerinde duran bir varlık değildir. O da doğanın değişen, dönüşen ve birbirine bağlı parçalarından biridir. Taoizm'in merkezinde bulunan Tao sözcüğü genellikle "Yol" olarak çevrilir. Ancak burada söz konusu olan, bir ye...

Taoism: The Ancient Art of Living in Harmony with the Way

Human beings often live with the belief that life can be controlled. They make plans for the future, try to anticipate problems before they arise, and work towards the outcomes they desire. Uncertainty makes them uncomfortable; they want events to unfold according to their expectations. Yet nature knows no such urgency. Rivers continue their course without attempting to remove every obstacle in their path. Trees do not compete with one another to grow, and the seasons follow their own cycles without waiting for each other. One of the oldest traditions in Chinese intellectual history, Taoism approaches the relationship between humanity, nature, and the universe from this perspective. Rather than focusing on humanity's efforts to govern the world, it is concerned with understanding the order in which we live. According to this way of thinking, human beings are not separate from the universe, nor do they stand above it. They are part of the same natural world, constantly changing and ...

The Great Mysteries of Humanity (2): Why Do We Dream?

Imagine walking through a city you have never seen before. The streets are unfamiliar, yet you know where you are going. Someone you have not seen in years is waiting a little further ahead. You hurry towards them, but suddenly find yourself in the house where you spent your childhood. The rooms are the same, the walls are unchanged, and even an object you lost years ago is still in its place. Everything seems perfectly natural. Then you wake up and realise that none of it actually happened. Yet the longing, fear, or joy you felt stays with you for a while. Part of the strangeness of dreams lies precisely here. We can experience events that never happened, meet someone who has died, return to the past, or accept things that could never occur in real life without questioning them. And while all this is happening, we often have no idea that we are dreaming. Humanity has been fascinated by this experience for thousands of years. Dreams have been interpreted as messages from the gods, sign...

Gastronomy Series (11): In Pursuit of Salt — How Did a Pinch of Salt Help Sustain Empires?

Salt is one of those things we rarely think about until it is missing. A dish can be carefully prepared, its ingredients perfectly balanced, yet without salt something feels incomplete. Today, it is an ordinary presence in kitchens around the world. We reach for it almost without thinking. But the history of salt extends far beyond taste. It offers a way to understand how human needs shape economic relationships, how geography creates dependencies, and how something seemingly insignificant can become part of the structures that sustain entire societies. Salt did not build empires on its own. Yet the need for it helped connect food production, trade, transportation, taxation and political authority. Its story reveals something larger than the history of a commodity: the way a basic necessity can influence the organization of human life. Before refrigeration and modern food storage technologies, preserving food was a constant concern. Meat and fish could spoil quickly, making it difficul...

The Architecture of the Soul: Locked Rooms and Hidden Archives

  Every building, every old house has a basement or an attic. Sometimes there is a room that has not been opened for years, a cupboard whose key has been lost, or boxes covered in dust, filled with things we can no longer remember. The human soul is not so different. From the outside, it may appear to be an orderly, completed structure, a place where life simply carries on. Yet deep within our inner world lie rooms whose doors we have not knocked on for years, drawers we have never touched, and hidden archives filled with traces of the past. Amid the rush of everyday life, the urgency of the present, and the noise of the outside world, we close the doors to these rooms and put their keys away in the deepest drawers of our minds. Sometimes we deliberately distance ourselves from them; sometimes, as time passes, we simply forget what we left behind. And yet, every now and then, an unexpected scent, an old song, a familiar street, or a single sentence spoken by someone can bring us ba...

Sky’s Language #4: The Houses of the Heavens — The Ascendant, the Houses, and the Map of Human Life in Ancient Astrology

  For humanity, looking at the sky was never simply a matter of observing the stars. People saw the changing seasons, the passage of time, the signs of the gods, and searched for answers about their own lives among the celestial bodies. Yet, over time, another question emerged: why did people born beneath the same sky lead such different lives? If two people were born on the same day, were their destinies supposed to be the same? In the development of ancient astrology towards the personal birth chart, this question became increasingly important. A new element joined the planets and the zodiac signs: the appearance of the sky at the precise moment and place of a person's birth. The celestial chart was no longer merely a record of where the planets stood. The horizon at the moment of birth, the Ascendant, and the twelve divisions of the heavens became part of a system used to interpret different areas of human life. These divisions, known today as astrological houses, were referred ...

The Contradictions of Being Human — Living Between Conflicting Desires

Human beings are strange creatures. Sometimes, within the span of a single day, we can want things that are entirely opposed to one another. We want to belong somewhere, yet we cannot tolerate anyone limiting us. We want to be loved, yet we might pull away from someone who genuinely tries to understand us. We talk about changing, we dream of a new life, but when it comes to disrupting the order we are used to, we hesitate. With one part of us, we run toward the future; with the other, we cannot let go of our past. And yet, despite being fully aware of all this, we continue to contradict ourselves. This is the most fascinating aspect of being human: We mostly want to see ourselves as consistent, sure of our decisions, and knowing what we want. Yet our inner world is a crowded place where opposing emotions, thoughts, and desires coexist. Even in moments when we think we know what we want, another desire can emerge and alter our entire balance. A human being cannot always stand on the sam...

İnsan Olmanın Çelişkileri -- Birbirine Zıt İstekler Arasında Yaşamak

İnsan tuhaf bir varlık. Bazen aynı gün içinde birbirine tamamen zıt şeyler isteyebilir. Bir yere ait olmak ister ama kimsenin kendisini sınırlamasına tahammül edemez. Sevilmek ister ama kendisini gerçekten tanımaya çalışan birinden uzaklaşabilir. Değişmekten söz eder, yeni bir hayatın hayalini kurar ama alıştığı düzeni bozmak gerektiğinde tereddüt eder. Bir yanıyla geleceğe koşarken diğer yanıyla geçmişinden kopamaz. Üstelik bütün bunların farkında olduğu hâlde kendisiyle çelişmeye devam eder. İnsan olmanın en ilginç tarafı budur: Kendimizi çoğu zaman tutarlı, kararlarından emin ve ne istediğini bilen varlıklar olarak görmek isteriz. Oysa iç dünyamız, birbirine zıt duyguların, düşüncelerin ve arzuların bir arada yaşadığı kalabalık bir yerdir. Ne istediğimizi bildiğimizi düşündüğümüz anlarda bile başka bir isteğimiz ortaya çıkıp bütün dengemizi değiştirebilir. İnsan, kendi içinde bile her zaman aynı tarafta duramaz. Özgür Olmak İsteriz Ama Güvende Hissetmekten Vazgeçemeyiz Özgürlük, ins...

Writing and Alchemy Series (14): Prima Materia — The First Matter from Which Everything Began

Is it possible for one substance to transform into another?  Can the structure of a metal be changed, can gold be obtained from an apparently worthless ore, or might different substances share an underlying essence? Today, with the development of chemistry, we can provide scientific answers to some of these questions. But for the alchemists who pursued them centuries ago, the matter was far broader. They did not simply want to change substances; they sought to understand how nature worked and what kind of order lay behind all these transformations. Prima Materia , or First Matter, is a concept that appears repeatedly in alchemical texts and lies at the heart of this search. Alchemists believed that the different substances found in nature might share a common point of origin, and that understanding this beginning could reveal the secret of transformation. Yet Prima Materia cannot be explained by identifying it with a single substance. In alchemical texts written in different period...